A Christmas Resolution

  A Christmas Resolution is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents are the products of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously. Any resemblance to actual events, locales, or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.

  Copyright © 2020 by Anne Perry

  All rights reserved.

  Published in the United States by Ballantine Books, an imprint of Random House, a division of Penguin Random House LLC, New York.

  BALLANTINE and the HOUSE colophon are registered trademarks of Penguin Random House LLC.

  Originally published in the United Kingdom by Headline Publishing Group, a Hachette UK Company.

  Hardback ISBN 9780593129586

  Ebook ISBN 9780593129593

  randomhousebooks.com

  Book design by Sara Bereta, adapted for ebook

  Cover illustration: Alan Ayers

  ep_prh_5.6.0_c0_r0

  Contents

  Cover

  Title Page

  Copyright

  A Christmas Resolution

  Dedication

  The Christmas Novels of Anne Perry

  About the Author

  Celia approached the vicar, who stood alone for a few moments in the shadow of the rounded arch above the doorway, sheltered from the rising wind. She wanted to say something about the excellence of his sermon beyond the usual “well done,” which covered anything and nothing.

  “That really was beautiful. You made me hear it again as good news,” she said with a smile. “I know the message is familiar, but the weight of meaning behind it felt new. You must know that.” She knew that he did not.

  As always at church, everyone was dressed in their Sunday best, women with bonnets and touches of fur, men with hats in their hands, the wealthier of them with rich astrakhan collars to match. And, of course, gloves. Everyone wore gloves. The cold winds blowing up off the Thames seemed to go straight through the layers of even the most expensive winter clothes. But at this moment, the departing congregation were all too spellbound by the vicar to feel the cold, as was Celia.

  Normally, the Reverend Arthur Roberson was not a very enthusiastic speaker. He was pleasant enough to look at, mild-mannered with an abundance of gray hair, although he was little over fifty. His voice was clear and well modulated, and he could sing with power. Usually, his sermons were competent, but not much more. However, today he spoke with an unaccustomed passion. Music filled his voice and his face was alight with the strength of his emotions.

  “That is the message of the gospel,” he said to her. “The meaning of Christmas for all mankind, indeed for all the earth. No one is excluded, from the first year of our Lord until this year of grace 1872. And always, there is repentance for any and all sins. You cannot commit an act, entertain a thought, that God does not know.” He spread his arms wide, his eyes shining. “You cannot imagine any sin He has not already seen, and forgiven, if only you repent. From the small everyday sins of thoughtlessness, not caring about the grief of others, all the pain done by indifference,” he shook his head, “all the way to the depths of violence or depravity that lie at the edge of nightmare, it is all reachable to God. Such is His mercy and understanding.”

  A man was approaching them, speaking to no one until he stood almost at the vicar’s elbow, where he could not be ignored. Seth Marlowe was a prominent member of the congregation, an outspoken leader of thought, which he expressed more often than Celia cared for. Celia was ashamed by how much she disliked him, but his opinions sounded to her unnecessarily rigid, unyielding, in places where she would have seen reason to make exceptions. One should temper the wind to the shorn lamb. What one person could disregard, another might find deeply wounding.

  She knew Seth Marlowe had suffered both the death of his wife some years ago now and the defection of his daughter, their only child. She told herself regularly that she should try harder to make an exception for him, even more so because he was the vicar’s brother-in-law. The vicar’s late wife had been his sister and had also died young, leaving two wildly different men to grieve for their wives. The women had also died very differently: Una Roberson of tuberculosis, slowly and with varying degrees of pain, but surrounded by deep love in her own home. The vicar still mourned for her quietly but had filled his life with carrying out his duties, ministering to the whole village with gentleness. To Celia, it sometimes looked like overindulgence, even a degree of weakness. But she was ashamed of that thought. She did not know the secrets of other people’s feelings: guilt, abandonment, hopelessness, loneliness, or even the fear that there was no justice, no forgiveness, and no love in the world.

  Rose Marlowe, on the other hand—at least according to her husband, Seth—had left home, abandoning him and taking their only child, who had since run off to God only knew where. Her father believed she was living on the streets. Rose had died, almost definitely by her own hand, leaving Seth haunted by a different kind of grief and a source of anger that never left him.

  Now Seth Marlowe was very clearly wanting to speak to the vicar and was not going to wait much longer.

  Celia reminded herself that she had never walked Seth Marlowe’s path in life. She knew she should be kinder. Not only to try to understand, but to acknowledge that she could not fully understand. But she could not like him, and she liked herself the less because of that.

  “Good morning, Mr. Marlowe,” Celia said, forcing a smile. “Wasn’t it an outstanding sermon? I’m sure everyone benefited from it and will go away the richer.”

  “I hope they will also go away better. After all, a good sermon is a great deal more than comforting, Miss…” He corrected himself. “…Mrs. Hooper. It is the true meaning of Christmas, which is too often overlooked in festivities.” He turned to the vicar, excluding Celia in the gesture. “Arthur, if I might have a word with you? I have something of importance to tell you.”

  “Of course,” the vicar replied. He always listened to anyone, no matter what they had to say.

  Celia wondered if he ever lost patience and told them to deal by themselves with whatever troubles they faced.

  “I wish you to be the first to know,” Marlowe said with a freezing glance at Celia, but she did not move. He had chosen a public place to interrupt. She was not going to be dismissed by him.

  Marlowe gave something close to a smile. “I am going to be married to Clementine Appleby. As soon as it can be arranged in all decency.”

  He went on talking, but Celia froze. Clementine was perhaps Celia’s closest friend in this village by the Thames, a stone’s throw away from London itself. Clementine was a little over thirty, still relatively young but old for a woman marrying for the first time, and from Celia’s own bitter experience of loneliness and exclusion, she understood Clementine well. Celia was just over forty, and less than a year before, she had married a man with whom she was deeply in love. It was a happiness she wished for everyone, especially Clementine, who, like herself, had no close family. But to be marrying Seth Marlowe? That bitter, cruel man. She couldn’t!

  Marlowe was staring at her now, his eyes critical. “Are you not happy for me, Mrs. Hooper? And for your friend Clementine? She will have a social position beyond yours, since your husband is a…dock laborer, or something of the sort…”

  “He is a senior officer in the Thames River Police,” she snapped. She wanted to add that she had married for love, not social position, but that would be petty and imply something of Clementine that she did not for a moment believe. Yet Clementine could hardly be marrying Marlowe for love.

  Marlowe stared at her with a smir
k.

  Celia drew in her breath to say something kinder, but Roberson spoke before her.

  “God is not a respecter of persons, Seth. Many of the greatest spirits come in the humblest form. You should not forget that. I think Clementine is one of them. You are very fortunate, and I trust you will care for her and make her happiness your greatest aim.” There was a pinched look in his face, a hollowness. Did he feel as shocked as Celia did, even afraid?

  “I should like to discuss arrangements with you,” Marlowe said to the vicar. “Privately, if you please.” He shot another cold look at Celia. “I do not wish Mrs. Hooper to participate. She is a bad influence on Clementine. She has…I do not wish to be unkind…unsuitable ideas about quite a lot of things.” He raised his voice slightly to be heard by others. “And has been mentioned in the newspapers.” He gave a sour smile. “Not the society pages, but court reports on crime. I will say no more, but I hope you understand, Arthur, that part of my duty toward the woman who will be my wife is to protect her from undesirable influences, and from scandal.”

  Celia felt as if she had been struck in the face. She was almost robbed of breath. She knew exactly what Marlowe was referring to, of course.

  It was a case about a year ago in which she had met John Hooper, who was an investigating policeman during the biggest tragedy of her life: the kidnapping and murder of her beloved cousin, Katherine. Katherine’s husband, Harry Exeter, had been accused of killing his wife as well as a woman prepared to give testimony against him. During that time, Celia found herself falling in love with Hooper. When Exeter had found out about Hooper’s earlier life as a seaman, and how he had led the crew against an unfit captain who nearly caused the drowning of every man on board, he used that information to force Celia to give Exeter an alibi. It didn’t matter to him that Hooper had saved all the crew’s lives, and to some extent the captain’s reputation. The only thing Exeter wanted was to walk free of two murders. If she lied, then Hooper’s secret would be kept. On the other hand, if she spoke what she knew, then Exeter would hang, but he would make damned sure that Hooper did, too. Because what Hooper had done to save lives had been a form of mutiny, which was a capital crime. Even if he, by some miracle, escaped the noose, he would certainly lose his job with the River Police. Celia had done the only thing she could: she had lied on the witness stand.

  Details of the case had been printed in the worst of the newspapers. They had made a very big deal of the fact that her obvious love for Hooper had driven her to commit perjury. The papers had omitted to say that she had been pardoned by the judge and never charged with anything.

  Standing outside the church now, staring at Marlowe as if mesmerized, her face burning, Celia felt all the misery and fear of that time overwhelming her. She had never told Arthur Roberson about it. It was humiliating to have been exposed to the public as a woman so blindly in love with a man who had made no advances toward her. It had sounded so desperate…and pathetic.

  Both men were staring at her now.

  It was Roberson who spoke first. “I am surprised that you read such newspapers, Seth. Muckraking. I had thought better of you. If you had chosen The Times, it would have told you that Exeter was found guilty, and of the superb work of the River Police in investigating the case, and the terrible death of Katherine Exeter—”

  “You never would face the truth about people, Arthur,” Marlowe returned. “You put women on a pedestal. Foolish. When they fall off, as they inevitably will, then they break more than their own reputations; they break other people’s hearts, and too often their spirits.”

  Roberson was speechless for a moment, overwhelmed by too many emotions.

  “Nevertheless,” Marlowe went on, “you will not involve Mrs. Hooper in any of my affairs. Is that clear?” He did not wait for an answer. He turned on his heel and strode away.

  Celia took a deep breath. “I don’t think he understood your message about forgiveness, Arthur.” She fought back tears and even managed a slight smile, before turning away and beginning to walk home.

  * * *

  Celia was halfway up the slight incline of the road toward her house and looking forward to its warmth, its sweet familiarity, when she heard footsteps behind her. She was in no mood for conversation, and the wind coming up off the river was knife-edged, finding every piece of her uncovered skin. She stopped and turned round just as Clementine Appleby reached her. Her eyes were shining and her fair skin was made pink by the wind. Perhaps she was not beautiful, and she definitely was on the wrong side of thirty, but she had a warmth that set her apart. Celia liked her quick humor and her joy in unexpected things: ducklings with little warm, flat feet; wreaths of mist on the river in the early morning light; crisp pancakes with lemon juice; the choice of a pink blouse when one might have expected the predictability of white.

  “I tried to catch you,” Clementine said, breathing in deeply. “Celia, I’m so happy! I can’t tell you everything just yet, but I simply had to tell you this. You always understand; you are just about the best friend I have ever had. I wish I could tell my mother.” For a moment her eyes misted over, then she controlled herself and blinked rapidly. She hardly ever mentioned any family, and Celia realized it was not a subject she could speak of. She had no brothers or sisters, and her mother had apparently died some time ago. Celia choked down her own feelings and forced herself to smile.

  “Would you like to come home for a cup of tea?” she offered. “The wind is cruel on this rise; I suppose it’s the price we pay for the view.” She gazed beyond Clementine to the wide stretch of water shining in the icy light, dotted with ships, barges, ferries, and occasionally pleasure boats, even in this season.

  “May I? That would be lovely, but won’t your husband be expecting his Sunday lunch?” Clementine asked hesitantly. She was always loath to intrude.

  “Not yet,” Celia promised her. “He’s on duty.”

  “It’s hard work in the River Police, isn’t it?”

  “Yes,” Celia said with pride. She was learning all the time what patience his work required: hardship and long hours on the water, in all weathers, and knowledge of winds and tides and of all manner of men, ships, cargoes, and weapons. She was in awe of his quiet strength, of spirit even more than of body.

  Clementine took a quick breath. “Celia, I am to be married!” Now the words burst from her, too big to be retained anymore or alluded to obliquely.

  Celia looked at her friend’s shining eyes, the smile she could not control. She knew something of the dreams that were hidden behind her protective cheerfulness, and much of it not long ago had been true of herself as well. Celia had married long after she had given up hope of ever having the safety or acceptance of marriage. Perhaps most of all, the sense of belonging. Love was another thing, a dream in itself. Celia had found them all and was savoring the strangeness, the excitement. She was still new to this. Of course, there were things hard to get used to: the lack of privacy at times, the need to bend, to change quite often, to keep opinions to herself. But it was wonderful.

  Instinctively, she put her arms around Clementine and hugged her, feeling her relax and return the embrace. “Wonderful!” she said heartily, stepping back a little. “I think I am nearly as happy for you as you are yourself. You have been so discreet; I really did not know.” Secretly, in her heart, she wished it were the vicar Clementine was going to wed. He was so terribly lonely and, in spite of the difference in their ages, she would be the perfect wife for him. The whole congregation would rejoice! But she must not let Clementine know that. Her smile must look real, surprised and happy.

  Clementine looked back at her, ignoring the freezing wind. “It is to Seth Marlowe,” she said. “He’s such a good man; I just hope I can make him happy, after all the grief he’s been through.”

  Celia was cold to the bone, as if all the layers of protective clothing had been torn from her, leaving her
skin naked to the knives of the wind.

  Clementine waited.

  Celia’s mind raced. She must be kind. She must not hurt this girl. Damn Seth Marlowe! “I had no idea.” That was stupid, she told herself. Say something good about him.

  “Don’t you think I will make him happy?” Clementine asked. “You don’t think I can keep up to his high standards?” There was a shadow across her face, in her eyes.

  Celia did not know what to say, and she knew Clementine had seen it already.

  “I am not of his social class,” Clementine added. “I know that. But I can learn. I can, Celia, I can learn.”

  “What on earth makes you think that?” Celia was shocked. Then, like a wave of memory came scores of little things that Clementine had said about her background, her lack of education, her lack of status. Celia had considered it unimportant and had never followed through with questions. “Clementine?”

  Clementine’s face was red with embarrassment, so different from the pleasure she had shown moments ago.

  “Clementine? What did your father do? What was his work?” She knew that was the standard by which people were apt to judge, however little it had to do with a person’s real worth.

  “I don’t know,” Clementine said in little more than a whisper. She looked down at the pavement, avoiding Celia’s eyes.

  “You don’t…” Celia began, then the truth struck her almost like a physical blow. “You don’t know who he was!” She gripped Clementine’s arms tightly, almost as if she were holding her up.

  “No.” The word was little more than a sigh.

  “And your mother raised you?” Celia asked.

  “Yes.” Clementine held her head high, her eyes defiant. “She gave me everything she could, she loved me, taught me, protected me…” The wind pulled a little of her hair loose, but she ignored it.

  “You don’t need to tell me that,” Celia replied with certainty. “I can see it in everything you are, say, and do. I am far more concerned that Seth Marlowe is not good enough for you.” This she meant as a bitter truth. If he hurt Clementine, that would be a sin for which God might forgive him, but Celia would not.